Most people spend decades building their retirement savings and feel confident when they reach their target number. But there's a risk almost nobody warns them about — one that has nothing to do with how much they've saved, and everything to do with when markets move.
It's called sequence of returns risk. And for anyone within ten years of retirement — or already retired — it may be the single most important concept in your entire financial plan.
Sequence of returns risk refers to the danger that poor market performance in the early years of retirement can permanently damage your income plan — even if long-term average returns are perfectly reasonable.
Here's the key insight: during your working years, the order that investment returns arrive doesn't matter very much. A bad year early on is offset by future growth, and you're adding to your savings throughout.
But once you retire and start drawing income from your portfolio, the order matters enormously. Taking withdrawals during a market downturn forces you to sell more shares to generate the same income — shares that can never recover for you personally, even if the market eventually does.
Consider two people, each retiring with $500,000 and withdrawing $25,000 per year. Both experience the same average annual return of 5% over 25 years. The only difference: the order of their returns.
Retiree A experiences strong gains in years one through five, followed by poor returns in later years.
Retiree B experiences poor returns in years one through five, followed by strong gains in later years.
Same average return. Same withdrawal amount. But the outcomes are dramatically different.
Retiree A's portfolio supports their income comfortably throughout retirement. Retiree B, selling shares at depressed prices in the early years, runs out of money in their late 70s — despite the market recovering strongly afterward.
The recovery came too late. The shares had already been sold.
The early years of retirement create what planners call the "sequence of returns window" — the period when your portfolio is at its largest and your withdrawals have the greatest proportional impact.
A 20% market decline when you have $500,000 and you're still working? Painful, but recoverable — you stop withdrawing and let the portfolio heal.
A 20% decline in year two of retirement, when you're withdrawing $25,000 a year? That's a fundamentally different problem. You're selling into weakness, depleting shares that can't grow back for you, and compressing the base from which all future growth must come.
Research consistently shows that retirees who experience a significant market downturn in the first five to ten years of retirement — even with sound long-run returns — face a meaningfully higher risk of running short of income later in life.
It is, in short, the worst possible time to be fully exposed to market risk.
Sequence of returns risk isn't theoretical. Anyone who retired in 2000 and held a market-weighted portfolio faced the dot-com crash in their first two years. Anyone who retired in 2007 faced the financial crisis within twelve months.
In both cases, retirees who had no income protection layer — no floor beneath their income that wasn't dependent on market performance — were forced to make painful choices:
→ Sell investments at the worst possible time to meet living expenses
→ Reduce their standard of living significantly and permanently
→ Return to work in their late 60s or early 70s
→ Deplete their portfolio far faster than any long-term projection suggested
Retirees who had built a layer of protected retirement income into their plan — income that continued regardless of market performance — were insulated from these forced decisions. Their essential expenses were covered. Their remaining portfolio had time to recover.
The good news is that sequence of returns risk is addressable. But like most retirement planning challenges, the best time to address it is before it becomes urgent — ideally in the five to ten years leading up to retirement.
The most effective protection against sequence of returns risk is ensuring that your essential monthly expenses are covered by income sources that don't depend on market performance. Social Security is one such source. There are also financial strategies specifically designed to generate guaranteed growth and protected retirement income — a reliable monthly amount that continues regardless of what markets do.
Holding 12 to 24 months of living expenses in cash or near-cash at retirement gives your invested portfolio time to recover from an early downturn without forcing you to sell at depressed prices.
Not all retirement accounts are treated equally by the tax code, and drawing from them in the wrong order at the wrong time can compound the damage from early losses. A deliberate withdrawal strategy — one that accounts for market conditions, tax efficiency, and income floor coverage — can significantly reduce the impact of poor early returns.
A retirement income plan built on the assumption of a smooth 7% annual return every year is not a plan — it's a projection. A robust plan stress-tests your income against scenarios where the first five years of retirement produce below-average returns, and builds in safeguards accordingly.
Your savings balance on the day you retire is important. But how your income plan is structured to handle the first decade of retirement — and specifically how it responds to market volatility during that window — may matter even more.
Sequence of returns risk is the reason that two people with identical savings and identical average returns can have completely different retirement outcomes. It's the reason that a large portfolio doesn't automatically mean a secure retirement income.
And it's the reason that every retirement plan should have an explicit, written answer to the question: what happens to my income if markets fall 30% in the first two years of my retirement?
If your current plan doesn't have that answer, that's the conversation to start now.
Ready to stress-test your retirement income plan? We offer complimentary retirement planning consultations for pre-retirees and retirees who want to understand exactly how their plan holds up — in any market environment.
📅 Book your complimentary consultation → https://calendly.com/d/cxhw-ysw-34z/initial-complimentary-consultation
.svg){kind=small}
